Discussion Project

Polarization or Propoganda

This project asks you to take a careful look at the article "Polarization or Propaganda" by C. Thi Nguyen

Discuss and try to agree on answers to the following questions:

1. What exactly is the "group polarization" theory? What explanation does it offer for the fact that people in the US are more politically polarized than in the past?

2. In what sense is this theory "symmetrical"?

3. According to Nguyen, what theory do Benkler and his coauthors offer for the phenomenon of political polarization in the US? (As a part of your answer, explain "the propaganda feedback loop.")

4. How is this theory "asymmetrical"?

5. Why does Nguyen think it is important to realize that a 'centrist' could be a victim of group polarization?

6. Why does Nguyen think that the propaganda story is more likely to be correct than the group polarization story?